From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Return-Path: Received: from dpdk.org (dpdk.org [92.243.14.124]) by inbox.dpdk.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id 6A4E6A0544; Thu, 13 Feb 2020 18:40:59 +0100 (CET) Received: from [92.243.14.124] (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by dpdk.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id 37C851C06C; Thu, 13 Feb 2020 18:40:59 +0100 (CET) Received: from qrelay61.mxroute.com (qrelay61.mxroute.com [172.82.139.61]) by dpdk.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id 3D5701C068 for ; Thu, 13 Feb 2020 18:40:57 +0100 (CET) Received: from filter003.mxroute.com ([168.235.111.26] 168-235-111-26.cloud.ramnode.com) (Authenticated sender: mN4UYu2MZsgR) by qrelay61.mxroute.com (ZoneMTA) with ESMTPA id 1703fa3ad31000088e.002 for ; Thu, 13 Feb 2020 17:40:56 +0000 X-Zone-Loop: e46df0b8ac205fc82f5bdb84ce52b435510d70141d81 X-Originating-IP: [168.235.111.26] Received: from galaxy.mxroute.com (unknown [23.92.70.113]) by filter003.mxroute.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id C62D260013; Thu, 13 Feb 2020 17:40:50 +0000 (UTC) Received: from [134.191.227.37] by galaxy.mxroute.com with esmtpsa (TLSv1.2:ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256:128) (Exim 4.91) (envelope-from ) id 1j2I9k-0000nb-AO; Thu, 13 Feb 2020 12:20:04 -0500 To: Neil Horman , Luca Boccassi Cc: Ferruh Yigit , Cristian Dumitrescu , Eelco Chaudron , dev@dpdk.org, Thomas Monjalon , David Marchand , Bruce Richardson , Ian Stokes References: <20200129122953.2016199-1-ferruh.yigit@intel.com> <20200202185334.GA6783@localhost.localdomain> <7beadbbd-bf0d-e545-d9bb-0e3ae8228b71@intel.com> <20200204120230.GA13754@hmswarspite.think-freely.org> <8eaaec5dedcfcf09ae69b15cc80ac1ff1a1f4a30.camel@debian.org> <20200205113245.GA17468@hmswarspite.think-freely.org> From: Ray Kinsella Autocrypt: addr=mdr@ashroe.eu; keydata= mQINBFv8B3wBEAC+5ImcgbIvadt3axrTnt7Sxch3FsmWTTomXfB8YiuHT8KL8L/bFRQSL1f6 ASCHu3M89EjYazlY+vJUWLr0BhK5t/YI7bQzrOuYrl9K94vlLwzD19s/zB/g5YGGR5plJr0s JtJsFGEvF9LL3e+FKMRXveQxBB8A51nAHfwG0WSyx53d61DYz7lp4/Y4RagxaJoHp9lakn8j HV2N6rrnF+qt5ukj5SbbKWSzGg5HQF2t0QQ5tzWhCAKTfcPlnP0GymTBfNMGOReWivi3Qqzr S51Xo7hoGujUgNAM41sxpxmhx8xSwcQ5WzmxgAhJ/StNV9cb3HWIoE5StCwQ4uXOLplZNGnS uxNdegvKB95NHZjRVRChg/uMTGpg9PqYbTIFoPXjuk27sxZLRJRrueg4tLbb3HM39CJwSB++ YICcqf2N+GVD48STfcIlpp12/HI+EcDSThzfWFhaHDC0hyirHxJyHXjnZ8bUexI/5zATn/ux TpMbc/vicJxeN+qfaVqPkCbkS71cHKuPluM3jE8aNCIBNQY1/j87k5ELzg3qaesLo2n1krBH bKvFfAmQuUuJT84/IqfdVtrSCTabvDuNBDpYBV0dGbTwaRfE7i+LiJJclUr8lOvHUpJ4Y6a5 0cxEPxm498G12Z3NoY/mP5soItPIPtLR0rA0fage44zSPwp6cQARAQABtBxSYXkgS2luc2Vs bGEgPG1kckBhc2hyb2UuZXU+iQJUBBMBCAA+FiEEcDUDlKDJaDuJlfZfdJdaH/sCCpsFAlv8 B3wCGyMFCQlmAYAFCwkIBwIGFQoJCAsCBBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQdJdaH/sCCptdtRAAl0oE msa+djBVYLIsax+0f8acidtWg2l9f7kc2hEjp9h9aZCpPchQvhhemtew/nKavik3RSnLTAyn B3C/0GNlmvI1l5PFROOgPZwz4xhJKGN7jOsRrbkJa23a8ly5UXwF3Vqnlny7D3z+7cu1qq/f VRK8qFyWkAb+xgqeZ/hTcbJUWtW+l5Zb+68WGEp8hB7TuJLEWb4+VKgHTpQ4vElYj8H3Z94a 04s2PJMbLIZSgmKDASnyrKY0CzTpPXx5rSJ1q+B1FCsfepHLqt3vKSALa3ld6bJ8fSJtDUJ7 JLiU8dFZrywgDIVme01jPbjJtUScW6jONLvhI8Z2sheR71UoKqGomMHNQpZ03ViVWBEALzEt TcjWgJFn8yAmxqM4nBnZ+hE3LbMo34KCHJD4eg18ojDt3s9VrDLa+V9fNxUHPSib9FD9UX/1 +nGfU/ZABmiTuUDM7WZdXri7HaMpzDRJUKI6b+/uunF8xH/h/MHW16VuMzgI5dkOKKv1LejD dT5mA4R+2zBS+GsM0oa2hUeX9E5WwjaDzXtVDg6kYq8YvEd+m0z3M4e6diFeLS77/sAOgaYL 92UcoKD+Beym/fVuC6/55a0e12ksTmgk5/ZoEdoNQLlVgd2INtvnO+0k5BJcn66ZjKn3GbEC VqFbrnv1GnA58nEInRCTzR1k26h9nmS5Ag0EW/wHfAEQAMth1vHr3fOZkVOPfod3M6DkQir5 xJvUW5EHgYUjYCPIa2qzgIVVuLDqZgSCCinyooG5dUJONVHj3nCbITCpJp4eB3PI84RPfDcC hf/V34N/Gx5mTeoymSZDBmXT8YtvV/uJvn+LvHLO4ZJdvq5ZxmDyxfXFmkm3/lLw0+rrNdK5 pt6OnVlCqEU9tcDBezjUwDtOahyV20XqxtUttN4kQWbDRkhT+HrA9WN9l2HX91yEYC+zmF1S OhBqRoTPLrR6g4sCWgFywqztpvZWhyIicJipnjac7qL/wRS+wrWfsYy6qWLIV80beN7yoa6v ccnuy4pu2uiuhk9/edtlmFE4dNdoRf7843CV9k1yRASTlmPkU59n0TJbw+okTa9fbbQgbIb1 pWsAuicRHyLUIUz4f6kPgdgty2FgTKuPuIzJd1s8s6p2aC1qo+Obm2gnBTduB+/n1Jw+vKpt 07d+CKEKu4CWwvZZ8ktJJLeofi4hMupTYiq+oMzqH+V1k6QgNm0Da489gXllU+3EFC6W1qKj tkvQzg2rYoWeYD1Qn8iXcO4Fpk6wzylclvatBMddVlQ6qrYeTmSbCsk+m2KVrz5vIyja0o5Y yfeN29s9emXnikmNfv/dA5fpi8XCANNnz3zOfA93DOB9DBf0TQ2/OrSPGjB3op7RCfoPBZ7u AjJ9dM7VABEBAAGJAjwEGAEIACYWIQRwNQOUoMloO4mV9l90l1of+wIKmwUCW/wHfAIbDAUJ CWYBgAAKCRB0l1of+wIKm3KlD/9w/LOG5rtgtCUWPl4B3pZvGpNym6XdK8cop9saOnE85zWf u+sKWCrxNgYkYP7aZrYMPwqDvilxhbTsIJl5HhPgpTO1b0i+c0n1Tij3EElj5UCg3q8mEc17 c+5jRrY3oz77g7E3oPftAjaq1ybbXjY4K32o3JHFR6I8wX3m9wJZJe1+Y+UVrrjY65gZFxcA thNVnWKErarVQGjeNgHV4N1uF3pIx3kT1N4GSnxhoz4Bki91kvkbBhUgYfNflGURfZT3wIKK +d50jd7kqRouXUCzTdzmDh7jnYrcEFM4nvyaYu0JjSS5R672d9SK5LVIfWmoUGzqD4AVmUW8 pcv461+PXchuS8+zpltR9zajl72Q3ymlT4BTAQOlCWkD0snBoKNUB5d2EXPNV13nA0qlm4U2 GpROfJMQXjV6fyYRvttKYfM5xYKgRgtP0z5lTAbsjg9WFKq0Fndh7kUlmHjuAIwKIV4Tzo75 QO2zC0/NTaTjmrtiXhP+vkC4pcrOGNsbHuaqvsc/ZZ0siXyYsqbctj/sCd8ka2r94u+c7o4l BGaAm+FtwAfEAkXHu4y5Phuv2IRR+x1wTey1U1RaEPgN8xq0LQ1OitX4t2mQwjdPihZQBCnZ wzOrkbzlJMNrMKJpEgulmxAHmYJKgvZHXZXtLJSejFjR0GdHJcL5rwVOMWB8cg== Message-ID: <20c7c2a7-54f7-996f-923a-82202ebc66eb@ashroe.eu> Date: Thu, 13 Feb 2020 17:40:43 +0000 User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; WOW64; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/68.4.2 MIME-Version: 1.0 In-Reply-To: <20200205113245.GA17468@hmswarspite.think-freely.org> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 Content-Language: en-US Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit X-AuthUser: mdr@ashroe.eu Subject: Re: [dpdk-dev] [RFC] meter: fix ABI break due to experimental tag removal X-BeenThere: dev@dpdk.org X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.15 Precedence: list List-Id: DPDK patches and discussions List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , Errors-To: dev-bounces@dpdk.org Sender: "dev" On 05/02/2020 11:32, Neil Horman wrote: > On Wed, Feb 05, 2020 at 11:04:29AM +0100, Luca Boccassi wrote: >> On Tue, 2020-02-04 at 07:02 -0500, Neil Horman wrote: >>>> But if we can do the versioning in the master, LTS can backport it >>>> and can have >>>> mature version of that API in LTS without breaking the existing >>>> users. >>>> >>> >>> But why bother? The only thing you've changed is the version >>> tagging. Its ok >>> to leave that alone in LTS, you just cant change it. >>> >>> Thats part of the burden of an LTS release, it will have some drift >>> from the >>> upstream head, because you have to keep things stable. So you >>> stabilize the >>> upstream ABI version for this API and just never backport it to the >>> current LTS >>> release. >> >> Hi, >> >> A customer (OVS) explicitly and specifically requested backporting the >> symbol change to 19.11, as they don't want to enable experimental APIs >> in their releases. I replied that it would only be acceptable with >> aliasing to keep compatibility, and Ferruh very kindly did the work to >> implement that. >> > but, thats part of the agreement, no? You can't always have new features and > stability at the same time. > > I get that this is an odd corner case, because strictly speaking you could waive > the ABI change that libabigail is reporting, and most application users (like > OVS) could get away with it, because their application does all the right things > to make it ok, but I don't think you can make a decsion like this for all users > based on the request of a single user. > > It seems like the right thing is for OVS to augment their build time > configuration to allow developers to select the ability to use experimental apis > at compile time, and then the decision is placed in the hands of end users. So this is not isolated case right ... it is common from API's to graduate from experimental to mature, we _want_ that to happen, we _want_ APIs to mature. I am worried what you are proposing will encourage a behavior whereby maintainers to wait until the declaration of the next major ABI version to make these symbol changes, causing these kinds of changes to queue up for that release. And you would have to ask why? In the case of a reasonably mature API, there will be no functional or signature change - its mature! So what is the harm of providing an alias back to Experimental until the next ABI version is declared? So while yes, you are 100% right - experimental mean no guarantees. But if the API is baked, it is not going to change, so I don't see the harm. We don't want the unnecessary triumph of policy over pragmatism.